Join the AMA (Ask Me Anything) with the Firefox leadership team to celebrate Firefox 20th anniversary and discuss Firefox’s future on Mozilla Connect. Mark your calendar on Thursday, November 14, 18:00 - 20:00 UTC!

Sykje yn Support

Mij stipescams. Wy sille jo nea freegje in telefoannûmer te beljen, der in sms nei ta te stjoeren of persoanlike gegevens te dielen. Meld fertochte aktiviteit mei de opsje ‘Misbrûk melde’.

Mear ynfo

Dizze konversaasje is argivearre. Stel in nije fraach as jo help nedich hawwe.

Firefox process stays behind after quit (Windows 10)

  • 3 antwurd
  • 1 hat dit probleem
  • 20 werjeftes
  • Lêste antwurd fan FredMcD

more options

When I quit Firefox, the process stays running forever; I have to open the task manager and kill it. (I wait until CPU usage is down to 0 so I know it's actually done, so it doesn't think it crashed.) Running Windows 10. I think this started more or less when the Anniversary Update landed.

To prevent wasted time from either party, here are some things I already tried:

  • disabled all extensions one by one
  • fresh profile
  • fresh install of Developer Edition
  • wiped all traces of Firefox from my system, and still got this on a fresh install → 32 and 64 bit, latest release, oldest release I was able to download, Developer Edition
  • switched antivirus
  • turned antivirus off entirely
  • Windows' own safe mode
When I quit Firefox, the process stays running forever; I have to open the task manager and kill it. (I wait until CPU usage is down to 0 so I know it's actually done, so it doesn't think it crashed.) Running Windows 10. I think this started more or less when the Anniversary Update landed. To prevent wasted time from either party, here are some things I already tried: * disabled all extensions one by one * fresh profile * fresh install of Developer Edition * wiped all traces of Firefox from my system, and still got this on a fresh install → 32 and 64 bit, latest release, oldest release I was able to download, Developer Edition * switched antivirus * turned antivirus off entirely * Windows' own safe mode

Bewurke troch lalomartins op

Alle antwurden (3)

more options
more options

Hi FredMcD, thanks for your reply. Here's the results along with some extra debugging:

  • crashfirefox.exe fails on my stable install (whether I run it while the process is hanging, or when it's running normally) with “Could not create remote thread.” I guess it's not 64b-compatible? With Developer Edition it hangs.
  • I couldn't find any other way to generate a crash report. I thought I could trick Developer Edition into doing it but no. Which makes sense since, well, it's not crashing. A report would only be meaningful if I could make it crash after it's in the hanging state, and that seems epistemologically difficult ;-)
  • Issue also happens in Safe Mode. (BTW it wasn't trivial at all to get to Safe Mode to start with, since the browser isn't able to restart.)
  • Playing around with a clean profile, I discovered one and only one situation where it exits successfully: if I change settings to “When Firefox starts: Show a blank page”, and then quit without navigating to anything at all, it quits. If I open anything at all, even the settings UI, the process hangs.
  • Memory usage displayed in the task manager after CPU reaches 0 varies according to how many tabs I had open and, I think, their content.
  • It makes no difference whether I close the window (using the X button or alt-f4) or exit Firefox via the menu.
  • And BTW it's not a matter of waiting it out. Sometimes I forget to kill it and it stays there hanging for hours while I'm doing Chrome work.
  • The Developer Edition install has multiprocess (Electrolysis) on, the stable install doesn't. That doesn't seem to make a difference. However, only one process stays behind. (That said, even when it's running, with 4 tabs open, I only see 2 processes — so maybe I misunderstand how Electrolysis works, or how to list/count processes on Windows.)

FredMcD said

How to crash Firefox; Instructions here; https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/How_to_report_a_hung_Firefox

You did not say if you tried Firefox in Safe Mode.


https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-hangs-or-not-responding

https://support.mozilla.org/kb/Firefox+is+already+running+but+is+not+responding

more options

Create a batch file on your Windows computer and call it something like ‘KillFirefox.bat’ Place this in the batch file;

TASKKILL /IM Firefox.exe /t

Now place a shortcut on the desktop to the batch.