Join the AMA (Ask Me Anything) with the Firefox leadership team to celebrate Firefox 20th anniversary and discuss Firefox’s future on Mozilla Connect. Mark your calendar on Thursday, November 14, 18:00 - 20:00 UTC!

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Thunderbird cannot read recovered emails in Outlook Inbox

more options

While managing my Thunderbird Inbox, I inadvertantly transferred a chunk of Inbox messages received from my MS Office365 Outlook account into the trash. I went into Outlook on the WebApp and discovered that all of the inadvertantly deleted emails were found under recover deleted emails. So within Outlook I recovered all mails into the Inbox. So far, so good.

Now I have all the mails listed in the Inbox on Outlook. But when I open Thunderbird again, the recovered mails do not show up. It seems that Thunderbird does not fully synchronize the folder and the recovered emails are not downloaded. Instead, all mails are once again removed from the Outlook Inbox. The previously recovered mails disappear again from the inbox of OWA and I have to recover them all again.

I have already tried several fixes. Within Outlook, I created a new folder and moved the recovered Inbox mails to that folder. This was done in the hope that this folder will then sync properly with Thunderbird. Unfortunately no. The folder does not sync and as soon as Thunderbird is closed again, all mails are deleted again from the new folder on OWA.

I also deleted the Outlook account (including all stored data) and recreated the account in Thunderbird. Unfortunately, the same thing happens again. The recovered mails are not displayed in Thunderbird and after closing the program, the mails are deleted again in OWA and I have to recover them again. Finally I went so far as to uninstall Thunderbird completely from my computer and reinstalled the software. That did not fix the problem either.

I will also provide another observation: in the past when I have recovered individual emails the same behavior has occurred. Seems that when Outlook or Exchange places a deleted email into the recovery queue, there is a change in its identify such that TB now views it as a deleted message.

Any suggestions on how this can be fixed?

Best regards

While managing my Thunderbird Inbox, I inadvertantly transferred a chunk of Inbox messages received from my MS Office365 Outlook account into the trash. I went into Outlook on the WebApp and discovered that all of the inadvertantly deleted emails were found under recover deleted emails. So within Outlook I recovered all mails into the Inbox. So far, so good. Now I have all the mails listed in the Inbox on Outlook. But when I open Thunderbird again, the recovered mails do not show up. It seems that Thunderbird does not fully synchronize the folder and the recovered emails are not downloaded. Instead, all mails are once again removed from the Outlook Inbox. The previously recovered mails disappear again from the inbox of OWA and I have to recover them all again. I have already tried several fixes. Within Outlook, I created a new folder and moved the recovered Inbox mails to that folder. This was done in the hope that this folder will then sync properly with Thunderbird. Unfortunately no. The folder does not sync and as soon as Thunderbird is closed again, all mails are deleted again from the new folder on OWA. I also deleted the Outlook account (including all stored data) and recreated the account in Thunderbird. Unfortunately, the same thing happens again. The recovered mails are not displayed in Thunderbird and after closing the program, the mails are deleted again in OWA and I have to recover them again. Finally I went so far as to uninstall Thunderbird completely from my computer and reinstalled the software. That did not fix the problem either. I will also provide another observation: in the past when I have recovered individual emails the same behavior has occurred. Seems that when Outlook or Exchange places a deleted email into the recovery queue, there is a change in its identify such that TB now views it as a deleted message. Any suggestions on how this can be fixed? Best regards

Modified by Matthew Kostura

All Replies (5)

more options

Is your account in Thunderbird POP or IMAP?

Helpful?

more options

The account is IMAP and the server I am using is smtp.office365.com. This particular setup has worked for me for quite some time without difficulty.

I have done a bit of testing and can reproduce the problem at will. Any email that is moved to the secondary delete (in Outlook speak that is "permanently" deleted but held in a separate space for recoverable emails NOT otherwise observed in the delete or trash folder) are not recognized by TB.

I found another thread on Substack where the contributor had exactly the same problem. They resolved the issue by routing the emails through another email client (they were working in a Linux environment and used Evolution). That email client recognized the Outlook emails as being deleted and they were found in the Evolution deleted items folder. The emails were moved to the Inbox (within the Evolution client) which updated the Outlook server and seemed to correct the problem. Thunderbird could now read the emails in the Inbox and they were downloaded and handled appropriately. Evolution did not install on my Windows based system. I installed eM client instead and it has the same issues as Thunderbird.

Modified by Matthew Kostura

Helpful?

more options

The email account is IMAP. The server is SMTP.office365.com.

I can reproduce the problem at will. On outlook if an email is permanently deleted it is moved from the "Trash" and into a secondary recycle bin. There the email is "recoverable" but not otherwise viewed in any folder. Any recovered email is put back into the Inbox ( or target folder) and can be viewed in Outlook. But those same emails are not observed in TB.

I found a message on Substack describing the exact same problem. Their solution is roundabout. They downloaded another email client (Evolution used in a Linux environment) which was able to read the recoverable emails as deleted. The deleted emails were placed back in the Inbox and voila, the Outlook server was updated and now, TB could see the emails. I am in a Windows environment and Evolution does not work. I installed eM client and that software has the same problem as TB.

Helpful?

more options

Let me make what I am understanding clear, because I am confused I think.

Outlook has some location that is not visible as an IMAP folder where it places mail that you have deleted permanently. You expect Thunderbird to not only know about this location, where ever it is, but access it despite it not being visible to the IMAP protocol being used to connect to the server.

BTW you send mail via an SMTP server all mail in all folders is accessed to view from an IMAP server. In the case of office365 it is outlook.office365.com I believe

Helpful?

more options

You are almost correct. Outlook has a secondary recycle bin that allows emails to be recovered for a specific period of times even if deleted. (Mine is set for 30 days) That repository is not visible in the Outlook folder view nor in TB. But, once emails are recovered from this repository, they are then returned to their originating folder (Inbox, Sent Mail, etc...). At this point Outlook can see the messages in the correct folder. TB cannot see those messages. And, if TB accesses the server, those emails are then deleted and they go back into the repository where they must be recovered again.

I have used a piece of software, Stellar OST viewer, that can read the local Outlook OST file. The recovered emails are in fact found in that file. I would expect that TB should be able to read them as well. But that does not happen.

Here is a link to a Stack Exchange site where I found a user reporting the exact same problem. https://superuser.com/questions/1793425/thunderbird-deletes-mails-after-recovering-on-owa

Helpful?

Uliza swali

You must log in to your account to reply to posts. Please start a new question, if you do not have an account yet.