Join the AMA (Ask Me Anything) with the Firefox leadership team to celebrate Firefox 20th anniversary and discuss Firefox’s future on Mozilla Connect. Mark your calendar on Thursday, November 14, 18:00 - 20:00 UTC!

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

All emails end up in new subfolder

  • 4 replies
  • 1 has this problem
  • 13 views
  • Last reply by Toad-Hall

more options

Dear fellow users of Thunderbird,

The title is my issue: After creating a new subfolder, all emails end up there, instead of the inbox or their appropriated folder.

Like almost everybody else, I have an email account. All emails are stored on the server of my email provider, and I have my email clients connected to it with IMAP. On my computer I use Thunderbird 78.8.1 to read my emails, and on my phone I use the native email app from LineageOS 17.1. Only my email client on my computer /Thunderbird has filters to sort all my emails in my inbox. Thus I just read my emails on my phone with the native, and read&sort emails on my computer with Thunderbird. All emails stay in my inbox, unless I open Thunderbird to sort&read my emails.

With the result that all emails stay in my inbox, unless I open Thunderbird to sort&read my emails to their appropriated (sub)folder. Only the new-new emails are staying in my inbox, and I have to set up and/or change some filters, to have these new-new emails sorted out to their appropriated (sub)folder.

But after creating a new subfolder this weekend and set three extra filters to sort some new-new emails to that new subfolder, all new emails go to that subfolder, instead of just these new-new emails. And I have checked it, neither my email client of my provider, nor the native email client of LOS have filters, just Thunderbird.

Although all filter settings are what they should be (as I have 15 filters, these are essay to check), all both known-new and new-new emails goes to the newly subfolder. Therefore I think I have found a bug in Thunderbird: After creating a new subfolder, all emails go to that new subfolder, despite all filters are set properly.

Iff I only have filters on Thunderbird, and all filters are set properly (I have checked them), then why go all known-new and new-new emails directly to that new subfolder?

Dear fellow users of Thunderbird, The title is my issue: After creating a new subfolder, all emails end up there, instead of the inbox or their appropriated folder. Like almost everybody else, I have an email account. All emails are stored on the server of my email provider, and I have my email clients connected to it with IMAP. On my computer I use Thunderbird 78.8.1 to read my emails, and on my phone I use the native email app from LineageOS 17.1. Only my email client on my computer /Thunderbird has filters to sort all my emails in my inbox. Thus I just read my emails on my phone with the native, and read&sort emails on my computer with Thunderbird. All emails stay in my inbox, unless I open Thunderbird to sort&read my emails. With the result that all emails stay in my inbox, unless I open Thunderbird to sort&read my emails to their appropriated (sub)folder. Only the new-new emails are staying in my inbox, and I have to set up and/or change some filters, to have these new-new emails sorted out to their appropriated (sub)folder. But after creating a new subfolder this weekend and set three extra filters to sort some new-new emails to that new subfolder, all new emails go to that subfolder, instead of just these new-new emails. And I have checked it, neither my email client of my provider, nor the native email client of LOS have filters, just Thunderbird. Although all filter settings are what they should be (as I have 15 filters, these are essay to check), all both known-new and new-new emails goes to the newly subfolder. Therefore I think I have found a bug in Thunderbird: After creating a new subfolder, all emails go to that new subfolder, despite all filters are set properly. Iff I only have filters on Thunderbird, and all filters are set properly (I have checked them), then why go all known-new and new-new emails directly to that new subfolder?

Chosen solution

Thanks, that was helpful, because I have found the bug. One of these three new filters does not have any rule set, as in the field is blank. Where I thought blank is nothing, Thunderbird seem to handle this blank field as everything. https://ibb.co/fdWtHKg

Solution A: Remove this filter Solution B: Possible to change Blank=Everything to Blank=Nothing? Solution C: Do both A and B.

Read this answer in context 👍 0

All Replies (5)

more options

Sorry for the typos, but it seem that I can not change my OP, pitty.

And yes, I can apply all filters to that new subfolder, to have things sorted out as I would like to have, but that is indeed a workaround...

Modified by 86ul

more options

I have still this issue, thus an update.

As I had created a subfolder within Thunderbird, I gave it a try to create a subfolder within email client of my provider. After 1) creating a new subfolder, 2) I moved all emails to the second subfolder, and then 3) I deleted the first subfolder.

But even then all emails end still up in that (second) subfolder.

A bug report it is than EDIT: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1719650

Modified by 86ul

more options

re: But after creating a new subfolder this weekend and set three extra filters to sort some new-new emails to that new subfolder,

Please post images of all three extra filters. Q: Are those three extra filters listed at the top of your Message Filter list?

Q: What is in the 'Filter Log ? 'Filter Log' is in the 'Message Filters' window - bottom right. Click on that button to open a new window to show you a list of actions with filters. If it is empty then it needs enabling. If it is not enabled: At the top, select the checkbox 'Enable Filter Log'. T Then close window and leave for a bit so new mail gets redirected by filter. Then access again to see the log. Post image of the log.

more options

Chosen Solution

Thanks, that was helpful, because I have found the bug. One of these three new filters does not have any rule set, as in the field is blank. Where I thought blank is nothing, Thunderbird seem to handle this blank field as everything. https://ibb.co/fdWtHKg

Solution A: Remove this filter Solution B: Possible to change Blank=Everything to Blank=Nothing? Solution C: Do both A and B.

Modified by 86ul

more options

Info from bug shows the logic to be incorrect.

'From' and 'Ends with' and nothing entered Move message to a folder