We're calling on all EU-based Mozillians with iOS or iPadOS devices to help us monitor Apple’s new browser choice screens. Join the effort to hold Big Tech to account!

Mozilla 도움말 검색

고객 지원 사기를 피하세요. 저희는 여러분께 절대로 전화를 걸거나 문자를 보내거나 개인 정보를 공유하도록 요청하지 않습니다. "악용 사례 신고"옵션을 사용하여 의심스러운 활동을 신고해 주세요.

자세히 살펴보기

Thunderbird with Oauth2 on own server support

  • 1 답장
  • 0 이 문제를 만남
  • 8 보기
  • 최종 답변자: next

more options

Hi,

I'm implementing an IMAP server with Oauth2 login capability.

My goal is to let user login to it using Thunderbird.

I have read in your documentation at https://wiki.mozilla.org/Thunderbird:Autoconfiguration:ConfigFileFormat under the Oauth2 section:

"Due to a defficiency in the OAuth2 spec, the client is usually required to send a client credential key, which in turn requires the client to be registered and approved by the email provider. Unfortunately, this not only allows email providers to block specific email clients (which is contrary to the idea of Open-Source), but also makes it impossible to support arbitrary OAuth2 servers. That's why Thunderbird is forced to hardcode the servers that it supports and the respecive client keys. That means that you cannot use OAuth2 for your own server. Only the servers listed on OAuth2Providers.jsm will work"

Is this true for the autoconfiguration process or for the whole oauth2 on own server support?

Right now I'm trying to login with a test account on mail system via Thunderbird configurated with Oauth2, from Dovecot I can see Thunderbird reaching the server and receiving response, after that Dovecot says:

"imap-login: Disconnected: Connection closed (no auth attempts in 0 secs)" and thunderbird hangs up indefinitely.

Just to know if I'have hope to make it work or not.

Many thanks

Gabriele

Hi, I'm implementing an IMAP server with Oauth2 login capability. My goal is to let user login to it using Thunderbird. I have read in your documentation at https://wiki.mozilla.org/Thunderbird:Autoconfiguration:ConfigFileFormat under the Oauth2 section: "Due to a defficiency in the OAuth2 spec, the client is usually required to send a client credential key, which in turn requires the client to be registered and approved by the email provider. Unfortunately, this not only allows email providers to block specific email clients (which is contrary to the idea of Open-Source), but also makes it impossible to support arbitrary OAuth2 servers. That's why Thunderbird is forced to hardcode the servers that it supports and the respecive client keys. That means that you cannot use OAuth2 for your own server. Only the servers listed on OAuth2Providers.jsm will work" Is this true for the autoconfiguration process or for the whole oauth2 on own server support? Right now I'm trying to login with a test account on mail system via Thunderbird configurated with Oauth2, from Dovecot I can see Thunderbird reaching the server and receiving response, after that Dovecot says: "imap-login: Disconnected: Connection closed (no auth attempts in 0 secs)" and thunderbird hangs up indefinitely. Just to know if I'have hope to make it work or not. Many thanks Gabriele

모든 댓글 (1)

more options

Ciao, ho aspettato un po' per vedere se qualcuno volesse intervenire, ma direi che è palese che la tua domanda sia troppo tecnica per un forum degli utenti. Posso solo suggerirti di chiedere sul forum internazionale in lingua inglese -> https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/ oppure chiedere sul forum di Mozilla Italia -> https://forum.mozillaitalia.org/

In alternativa prova ad aprire una segnalazione su bugzilla -> https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/describecomponents.cgi?product=Thunderbird