We're calling on all EU-based Mozillians with iOS or iPadOS devices to help us monitor Apple’s new browser choice screens. Join the effort to hold Big Tech to account!

Kërkoni te Asistenca

Shmangni karremëzime gjoja asistence. S’do t’ju kërkojmë kurrë të bëni një thirrje apo të dërgoni tekst te një numër telefoni, apo të na jepni të dhëna personale. Ju lutemi, raportoni veprimtari të dyshimtë duke përdorur mundësinë “Raportoni Abuzim”.

Mësoni Më Tepër

Thunderbird folder compacting changes old message headers which greatly increase size of incremental backups

  • 5 përgjigje
  • 0 e kanë hasur këtë problem
  • Përgjigjja më e re nga Marcin

more options

Hi,

TL;TR. Thunderbird should not change the whole folder (e.g. Inbox) during compacting by replacing "From" with "From - Mon May 3 20:50:30 2004" and the other way round. It dramatically increases the size of incremental backups done by tools detecting only blocks of bigger files which change.


Longer version. I use Borg to backup Thunderbird profile. It supports deduplication and can incrementally backup only parts of bigger files which have changed. As I use filters to automatically move messages from Inbox to the other folders, before backup, I perform compacting of the Inbox folder to effectively remove moved messages (and those deleted manually - e.g. the biggest ones). I worked pretty fine - there were no changes detected by Borg in the old messages. Only new messages were backed up.

However, it worsen in the recent months - Borg started to detected changes also in the old messages in Inbox (after compacting performed before the every backup session). As a result, a (compressed) incremental copy takes ~1/3 of the whole Inbox (instead of some MBs). For Inbox having 5GB+, it can be a problem (e.g. when - slow - network storage is used).

I diffed the Inbox file before and after of recent compacting and Thunderbird around an upgrade to 128.x (I cannot tell exactly which minor version it was) changed the "From" line for every message from just "From" to "From - Thu Nov 14 22:32:10 2024" (a date when the compaction was performed). In older backups I see that some earlier versions of Thunderbird removed the date replacing the line with just "From".

My question. Had it been an accidental change (with removing the date) which was later reverted and there will be no more "rewriting" compacted folders? Or it's "more complicated" and people using incremental backup cannot sleep peacefully?


Marcin

P.S. Let's skip the msf files for the moment as they are much smaller.

Hi, TL;TR. Thunderbird should not change the whole folder (e.g. Inbox) during compacting by replacing "From" with "From - Mon May 3 20:50:30 2004" and the other way round. It dramatically increases the size of incremental backups done by tools detecting only blocks of bigger files which change. Longer version. I use Borg to backup Thunderbird profile. It supports deduplication and can incrementally backup only parts of bigger files which have changed. As I use filters to automatically move messages from Inbox to the other folders, before backup, I perform compacting of the Inbox folder to effectively remove moved messages (and those deleted manually - e.g. the biggest ones). I worked pretty fine - there were no changes detected by Borg in the old messages. Only new messages were backed up. However, it worsen in the recent months - Borg started to detected changes also in the old messages in Inbox (after compacting performed before the every backup session). As a result, a (compressed) incremental copy takes ~1/3 of the whole Inbox (instead of some MBs). For Inbox having 5GB+, it can be a problem (e.g. when - slow - network storage is used). I diffed the Inbox file before and after of recent compacting and Thunderbird around an upgrade to 128.x (I cannot tell exactly which minor version it was) changed the "From" line for every message from just "From" to "From - Thu Nov 14 22:32:10 2024" (a date when the compaction was performed). In older backups I see that some earlier versions of Thunderbird removed the date replacing the line with just "From". '''My question'''. Had it been an accidental change (with removing the date) which was later reverted and there will be no more "rewriting" compacted folders? Or it's "more complicated" and people using incremental backup cannot sleep peacefully? Marcin P.S. Let's skip the msf files for the moment as they are much smaller.

Zgjidhje e zgjedhur

Marcin said

Maybe they do not realize the impact of those changes? I will try to run this topic using the developers group - https://thunderbird.topicbox.com/groups to ask about the plans .

Btw, I've found that developer thread which explains the situation: https://thunderbird.topicbox.com/groups/developers/T474524e1d82fbdd1

Lexojeni këtë përgjigje brenda kontekstit 👍 0

Krejt Përgjigjet (5)

more options

If you are seeing this once per folder, that is normal. The file format has changed.

E dobishme?

more options

Wayne Mery said

If you are seeing this once per folder, that is normal. The file format has changed.

Unfortunately, as I stated in the original message, there were at least 2 changes - back and forth (each generating GBs of extra overhead), separated by 1-2 months. Therefore, I posted it here, to try to explain, if it was a "bug" or it is unstable and there might be further changes?

E dobishme?

more options

Thanks. Yes, I believe there were multiple changes. We can't predict what development will do in the pursuit of improving the product.

E dobishme?

more options

Wayne Mery said

Thanks. Yes, I believe there were multiple changes. We can't predict what development will do in the pursuit of improving the product.

Maybe they do not realize the impact of those changes? I will try to run this topic using the developers group - https://thunderbird.topicbox.com/groups to ask about the plans .

Thanks for your comments.

E dobishme?

more options

Zgjidhja e Zgjedhur

Marcin said

Maybe they do not realize the impact of those changes? I will try to run this topic using the developers group - https://thunderbird.topicbox.com/groups to ask about the plans .

Btw, I've found that developer thread which explains the situation: https://thunderbird.topicbox.com/groups/developers/T474524e1d82fbdd1

Ndryshuar nga Marcin

E dobishme?

Bëni një pyetje

Duhet të bëni hyrjen te llogaria juaj që t’i përgjigjeni postimeve. Ju lutemi, filloni me një pyetje të re, nëse nuk keni ende një llogari.